User Reviews
Rating: really liked it
Spoiler: Donald Trump is incompetent and misogynistic.
Surprise!Well, I couldn’t help myself, could I? This book is causing such a stir that I just had to read it. I can't let that controversial bandwagon just pass me by. Having read it, though, I have to say I'm surprised that it's causing such a stir at all. There's very little here that people don't already know about Trump, Bannon, Kushner and Russia.
I guess maybe I can see the value in putting together an overview of the Trump campaign and presidency, but unfortunately this book is also poorly-written, contains no references, and reads a little bit like, um, fake news. Sorry to say it. What it contains in new material - such as snatches of conversations, and the true feelings of Trump & Co. - is written in an
extremely sensationalist, tabloid style, without anything to back it up.
I can understand why even Trump’s toughest critics have had some doubts about this book. Wolff writes things it seems he couldn’t possibly know without explaining why he does, in fact, know them (who overheard that thing that Bannon said? How can he say what Trump is thinking in a particular moment?). I know a lot of it had to be anonymous, but he often expresses the feelings of individuals, even Trump himself, on certain matters without saying how he knows it (not even so much as “an insider told me…”).
There are many hard-working journalists who have written fantastic, well-researched critiques of Trump and his presidency. These articles fill me with such satisfaction because they are a perfect contrast to Trump’s ranting, tweeting nonsense, but Wolff instead prefers to play the Trump game. His book seems written with the intention of being as provocative and antagonistic as possible. It evokes emotions, but adds little to the discussion.
The result is a book that is full of unsubstantiated assertions. Characteristic of our times - and this presidency in particular - the book feels gossipy, based around emotions and talking the loudest, instead of being convincing and analytical, backed up by solid references that we can factcheck.
I am critical of Trump because, among many other things, he constantly says and tweets baseless accusations and theories that are meant to incite a passionate response. But that's exactly what Fire and Fury does, too.
Blog | Facebook | Twitter | Instagram | Youtube
Rating: really liked it
This book was hilarious and terrifying and confirmed pretty much everything most of us have suspected about the incompetence of the Trump administration. If even half of this book is true, well, this presidency is a disaster.
The strangest part of this book is Wolf’s unabashed affection for Steve Bannon. Like, dude, get a room.
Also this book is sloppy and needs to be edited.
Rating: really liked it
I never planned on reading this. But now that Donald Trump is trying to prevent its release, it's now the highest priority on my reading list.
Rating: really liked it
MUELLER IS COMING!
Da-ta da-da-dah-ta da-da-dah-ta da-da-dah-ta
da-da-dah-ta da-da-dah-ta da-da-dah-ta da-da-dah-ta da-da
Daaaa da dadada dah da-dudaaaah
Daaaa da dadada dah dududaaaah
Michael Wolff has given us a drone’s (dragon’s?) eye view of the competing centers vying to be the power behind the throne, with some looking, in the longer term, at carving paths for their own succession to the highest position in the realm. There is a mad king who needs to be handled. Centers of power arise, morph, wage battles both silent and overt, succeed and fail, rise, die, and sometimes rise again. What we see in Michael Wolff’s
Fire and Ice Fury, from our lofty perch, is the geography of chaos in the known world of the White House. Games will be played. Backs will be stabbed. Sadly, there is no magic, only sleight of hand. And it remains to be seen if nuclear dragons will be unleashed.
The juicy bits of this book have been everywhere for the last few weeks. It is highly quotable, and the publisher, Holt, the author, their PR people, and the major news outlets have been flooding the zone. Whether on-line or in print, over airwaves on TV or radio, through cable, and probably via the deep-state-news (WDSN?) that beams directly into peoples’ minds, all media have been all agog with the many looks at this elephant to which they have been privy.
With so much blanket coverage coming at you, one might be forgiven for wondering whether you first saw the item you just read in the book, or came across it somewhere else. It is a little bit unnerving. I will spare you the further confusion of adding
all those bits here. I really have to put some in, though. I mean you know them already, right? How many synonyms can you find for
idiot?
Fire and Fury is the biggest book of the moment, the Wall Street Journal reporting that it had sold a million copies as of Monday, January 8, 2018, a day
earlier than its scheduled release. Remains to be seen, of course, with a steady stream of books on Trump being published, how long this frenzy will persist. But the last time I was aware of people standing on line for hours to get a book, it included the words
Harry and
Potter. This book, in the words of our former vice president, is a big fucking deal.
Michael Wolff - image from Mediaite.com
The bottom line of
Fire and Fury is that it presents Donald Trump as unfit to serve as president, based not on the dark view and negative press of his opposition, but the been-there-OMG-did-you-see-that experience of his own staff and supporters.
Almost all the professionals who were now set to join him were coming face to face with the fact that it appeared he knew nothing. There was simply no subject, other than perhaps building construction, that he had substantially mastered.
Wolff uses named and unnamed sources. It seems clear that his primary go-to was one Steve Bannon, a weaver of webs, a bomb-thrower, a snake in the grass, a back-stabber, a manipulator, a white supremacist, a gifted media manipulator, and a pretty bright and articulate, if sartorially challenged guy. One might be tempted to dismiss Wolff’s book based on this reliance. Don’t. There are plenty of other sources feeding the narrative. The question is whether the image Wolff generates by making a composite of the incoming bits makes sense. Is it plausible? Is it correct? Having seen Wolff interviewed on multiple news and entertainment shows, and attending to the back-and-forths between him and knowledgeable news people, it seems eminently clear that he got it right. There are probably some details that err a bit here and there. Maybe this person was not at that meeting, or a date may be off. I expect that the only inaccuracies to be found here will be of that sort. Niggling, beside the point. And blown way out of proportion by those with an interest in distracting you from the core content of the book. That the president attempted to stop its publication should tell you something.
What was, to many of the people who knew Trump well, much more confounding was that he had managed to win this election, and arrive at this ultimate accomplishment, wholly lacking what in some obvious sense must be the main requirement of the job, what neuroscientists would call executive function. He had somehow won the race for president, but his brain seemed incapable of performing what would be essential tasks in his new job. He had no ability to plan and organize and pay attention and switch focus; he had never been able to tailor his behavior to what the goals at hand reasonably required. On the most basic level, he simply could not link cause and effect.
Michael Wolff is a veteran author and journalist, with seven prior books to his credit. He has been nominated for the National Magazine Award three times, and accused by people he has written about of fabricating. The absence of actual lawsuits against him suggests that complaints were less than firmly grounded. He is a serious writer and should be taken seriously. It is a bit mind-boggling the access he had to the actual White House, but he lays it out. He hung out in the WH, with a huge degree of access and was able to get input from the people working or passing through there, for months. Was the administration insane for allowing this? You betcha. But they did, another sign of their unpreparedness.
Inauguration day offered a look at what was to come.
Much of the sixteen-minute speech was part of Bannon’s daily joie de guerre patter—his take-back-the-country America-first, carnage-everywhere vision for the country. But it actually became darker and more forceful when filtered through Trump’s disappointment and delivered with his golf face. The administration purposely began on a tone of menace—a Bannon-driven message to the other side that the country was about to undergo profound change. Trump’s wounded feelings—his sense of being shunned and unloved on the very day he became president—helped send that message. When he came off the podium after delivering his address, he kept repeating, “Nobody will forget this speech.”
George W. Bush, on the dais, supplied what seemed likely to become the historic footnote to the Trump address: “That’s some weird shit.”
As noted above, the geography through which Wolff’s tale travels is one of sundry kingdoms. I could not help but imagine the opening credits of
Game of Thrones as we approach each power center, the models for each of the city-states animating, offering moving, 3-D representations of each kingdom’s imagery and motifs. The three (sadly, not seven) are the alt-right of Bannon and his allies (clearly White Walkers), the mainstream GOP crowd epitomized by Reince Preibus, and the family wing, considered by Bannon to be of a liberal-democratic bent, in the person of Jared Kushner and the president’s daughter, Ivanka Trump, aka Jarvanka. (Cersei and Jamie?).
Swamp Thing as Joffrey Baratheon- image from DesignCrowd.com, by way of Huff-Po
The forward motion of the story is the events of Trump’s campaign, but mostly presidency up to October, 2017. I know, I know. One of the problems with political books is that they can often be outdated in fairly short order. The several months between October and the book’s publication is a lifetime in Trump years. It is impressive, given the daily churning of personnel and events in the DC universe (not the multiverse) these days that
any book on Trumplandia still has relevance by the time ink on paper makes its way to readers. And yet, the issues raised here, the main issue, is momentous, and sticks.
Wolff has offered a host of quotes from his sources, many named, that question Swamp Thing’s competence, not just to function as president, but to function as a human being. His own staff frequently mention the applicability of the 25th amendment (although in the real world that is a total fantasy) and the likelihood of impeachment. The sound of Robert Mueller’s approaching steps echoes throughout the work, clearly feeding Trump’s paranoia about being treated unfairly, and boosting his fear of being found out, labeled a squatter or deadbeat, and evicted.
In most White Houses, policy and action flow down, with staff trying to implement what the president wants—or, at the very least, what the chief of staff says the president wants. In the Trump White House, policy making, from the very first instance of Bannon’s immigration EO, [executive order] flowed up. It was a process of suggesting, in throw-it-against-the-wall style, what the president might want, and hoping he might then think that he had thought of this himself (a result that was often helped along with the suggestion that he had in fact already had the thought).
Wolff, with his title, and content, offers a wonderful
Game of Thrones image. But there are plenty more that could easily apply. The Producers is one that he mentions, a particularly apt metaphor, given that it seemed clear to many of us, even during the campaign, that Trump, like Bialystock and Bloom, got into the presidential race for the money, and never really intended to win. This is confirmed in the book. Personally, I think Max Bialystock would have made a better president. Another scenario that Wolff mentions is the relationship of Thomas Cromwell to Henry VIII, wonderfully portrayed in the novel Wolf Hall (no relation), with Steve Bannon in the Cromwell role and you-know-who as the guy who made such a gigantic mess, because he simply had to have things his way. One could also consider
House of Cards (the original), with all the plotting, back-stabbing, and hunger for power that made that series such fun to watch, although, after Bannon as Francis Urquart, the personnel parallels fade a bit.
Alice in Wonderland gives us Trump as the single-minded Queen of Hearts.
The Gang That Couldn’t Shoot Straight might offer an image of ineptitude, if one ignores the fact that Trump has overseen the greatest looting by criminals of the national treasury in the nation’s history. For all his intellectual challenges Swamp Thing is a larger than life character with very little core, a made-for-Television president.
Swamp Thing and Bannon as Henry VIII and T. Cromwell - image from NY Magazine
One of the things I most enjoyed was Wolff’s take on
The Mooch. Anthony Scaramucci is the sort of Damon Runyon hanger-on one might expect to see in Guys and Dolls, or maybe a Batman flick, all puffery and attitude smeared over a core of ignorance, inflated by cartoonishly excessive self-confidence and corruption. From the description in
Fire and Fury, it is not hard to imagine him in a too-wide pin-striped suit, shoulder-padded, sporting excessive pancake makeup, swinging a pocket watch from a chain, and laughing uncontrollably as he kicks some poor shmo that his minions are holding down for him, because he was a few dollars short on his protection payment.
There are some things missing from the book, of course. There is not the sort of detailed biographical material better found in an actual biography. Forget seeing an autobiography. Anything Trump truly wrote would probably be close to an actual choose-your-own-adventure kid book, given his inability to remain focused for more than a few minutes. There is not a lot about serious international threats, with one exception. In a press conference at his Bedminster, NJ property:
“His staff had not prepared him for this, but, in apparent relief that he could digress from the opioid discussion, as well as sudden satisfaction at the opportunity to address this nagging problem, he ventured out, in language that he’d repeated often in private—as he repeated everything often—to the precipice of an international crisis.
“North Korea best not make any more threats to the United States. They will be met with the fire and the fury like the world has never seen. He has been very threatening beyond a normal state, and as I said they will be met with fire and fury and frankly power, the likes of which this world has never seen before. Thank you.”
Thus an increased concern about the danger of someone implementing the launch codes in a fit of pique or confusion. A fair bit of that intercontinental exchange of verbal ordnance occurred after the book was written, most notably the “My Button is bigger than your Button” lunacy. There is little discussion, although it gets a mention, of the potential implications of Trump’s autocratic leanings. The telling of the tale is much more about what has already happened as opposed to what might.
It was during Trump’s early intelligence briefings, held soon after he captured the nomination, that alarm signals first went off among his new campaign staff: he seemed to lack the ability to take in third-party information. Or maybe he lacked the interest; whichever, he seemed almost phobic about having formal demands on his attention. He stonewalled every written page and balked at every explanation. “He’s a guy who really hated school,” said Bannon. “And he’s not going to start liking it now.”
This is not a book about policy. It is portrait of a White House as a theater of political warfare, a candidate who never really wanted or expected to be president and a president who is not only completely out of his depth, but who shows not only no capacity, but no interest in learning to swim. Even the people who work for him see him as unintelligent, narcissistic, incurious, and lazy. They even suggest he is losing his grip on reality, presuming he ever had one. It is certainly entertaining, the bits about Trump’s TV addiction, how he manages to cover his bald pate, and his pettiness about not wanting the cleaning staff to pick up his clothes from the floor. I mean, really, is he ashamed of being seen as a slob? Eating burgers in bed in front of the TV will probably gain him more support than criticism. I mean, even I can get on board with that, and I do not have a kind view of the man. But the more serious element is his mental fitness, and the danger this presents to us all.
image from Wolff’s Twitter feed, citing the Hollywood Reporter
There is zero chance that the Republican Party will allow their sitting president, however damaged or corrupt he is, to be removed from office under the 25th Amendment. The best chance for his leaving office is for him to suffer a serious physical health crisis, which might force him to resign. As an older, overweight, out of shape man, this is not far-fetched. Even with a Democratically controlled Congress in January 2019, there is no guarantee that the Senate would come up with the sixty-seven votes needed to convict. The significance of this is that until Donald John Trump is removed from the presidency, by impeachment, ill-health, death, or being voted out of office in 2020, we are all at risk.
Michael Wolff’s
Fire and Fury is an air-raid siren warning us all of peril, real and potential. (Wolff Hell?) It is must-read material for every American. When the GOP stands in the way of investigations into the administration, they are supporting a president who is unable to function at the needed level, a president who is uninterested in the details of governance, a president who is not in control of himself, a president who places not only himself, but the nation, and the entire world at risk. You need to know what they are protecting. It doesn’t take a stable genius to know that you should be afraid, very afraid. As Dubyah said, “That’s some weird shit.”
Published – January 9, 2018
Review Posted – January 12, 2018
==========In the summer of 2019 GR reduced the allowable review size by 25%, from 20,000 to 15,000 characters. Then in Summer 2021 they decreed that external links would not longer be allowed in comments, where I used to put the review overage. So I have included the entirety of the review, including EXTRA STUFF, on my site, Coot’s Reviews. Stop by and say Hi!
Rating: really liked it
Find all of my reviews at: http://52bookminimum.blogspot.com/
When I initially posted the "review" below (based solely on leaked segments) the day before
Fire and Fury was officially released, I had no idea my little bit of nothing would get as much attention as it has. I also didn't really plan on reading the book. But then somehow the library decided it should order
SIXTY copies of the thing and I went from 90th on the wait list to it being my turn before even a week was over (many thanks to the patrons who either removed their names from the list or made a point to return the book right away so everyone could get their chance) and there was a snow day so I had no excuse not to dive right in. So what do I think now that I'm finished? Well, I think we elected fucking Fredo to run our great nation . . . .
I stand behind everything I said before. This was indeed simply a "tell-all" as I originally believed and probably contained a "bigly" chunk of tabloid journalism (which surprisingly focused A LOT on the Bannon/Jared & Ivanka relationship). It's convenient that one of the most quoted figures in the book is Roger Ailes who is now dead. But at the end of the day does it really matter which quotes are real or who leaked what when it comes to sort of a "National Enquirer" type of bestseller? Trump said it best when he said the following about his supporters:
"I could stand in the middle of 5th Avenue and shoot somebody and I wouldn't lose voters." If nothing else has been confirmed for me since the inauguration (aside from the fact that Trump had the biggest crowd ever in attendance *eye roll*) it is Trump's own quote above and this point that
Fire and Fury makes over and over and over again . . . .
"He could not even attempt to imitate decorum." And
THAT is something that no one will ever be able to fix when it comes to this 71-year old man. Let's just hope America wakes up by the next election before Trump turns our country into a "shithole nation." : (
INITIAL THOUGHTS:Today our Führer is attempting to prevent this book’s release. People quoted in the book are also coming forth denying they said some of the things attributed to them. If a copy of this (literally) falls into my lap – like from the sky while I’m sitting on a park bench or something – I may read it. As for what has been leaked so far regarding its contents? All I have to say is . . . . .
OF COURSE Trump didn’t think he would win the G.D. election. No one in the universe did. He put his name in the hat as a marketing ploy for his failing brand. Unfortunately for America, no one drinks the Trump Kool-Aid as well as Trump himself so once he was told there was a chance he could win he brainwashed himself into thinking he was qualified for the job.
OF COURSE he sleeps in a different bedroom than Melania. Melania had ZERO intention of ever moving from her gilded penthouse in Trump Tower until the powers that be told her she was obligated to for the sake of public appearance. It’s not like she really hides her distaste when it comes to her husband . . . .
OF COURSE Rupert Murdoch called him a “fucking idiot.” HE IS ONE. I guarantee Tillerson called him a moron too.
OF COURSE he is so delusional he believes someone would poison him. Hell, it’s probably someone in his own family … or someone who married into his family only to be used as a patsy.
OF COURSE he hates the Obamas. Every single move he’s made since being elected is an attempt to delete Obama’s footprint from the history books. At this point one could only be thankful if the reasoning behind Trump’s disdain is because they were “very arrogant” rather than because The Donald wears a white robe and hood around Mar-A-Largo on the weekends.
OF COURSE Ivanka has her eye set on being the first female president. It’s pretty obvious at this point the Trumps like to fancy themselves as a new and not-so-improved version of the Kennedy clan.
OF COURSE Trump doesn’t read or “really even skim,” but instead engrosses himself in television viewing in order to see just how “fake” the news is that day in order to be able to Twat about it while taking his 3:00 a.m. constitutional every night after his handlers have retired to their beds. Is it really surprising Trump isn't a big reader? He is, after all, the dude who has “the best words” such as . . . .
OF COURSE Steve Bannon used him . . . .
Once again
DUH MOTHERFUCKER. You were the only one stupid enough to believe a fucking white supremacist had the best interest of the country at heart.
OF COURSE everyone who works in the White House right now hates everyone else. Kelly hates everyone most of all. Thank Jeebus he loves this country enough to keep trying to stomp out the dumpster fire which is this presidency with his bare feet every day.
Was I the only person who equated this release to a Kitty Kelley sort “unauthorized biography????” Now, thanks to Trump and his merry band of minions – along with their cease and desist demands, this is sure to be a bestseller . . . .
Rating: really liked it
Donald Trump has loudly complained that he would be able to sue the author of
Fire and Fury, were it not for the fact that US libel law is so weak. I thought I would look a few things up.
According to the Wikipedia article, libel law is indeed less plaintiff-friendly in the US than in most countries. In particular, truth is an absolute defense, i.e. true statements cannot be defamatory. However, if
Fire and Fury does contain false and defamatory statements, it seems to me that Trump would have decent prospects of winning a case. It would be necessary to prove "actual malice", namely "knowledge that the information was false" or that it was published "with reckless disregard of whether it was false or not", and also that the allegations or imputations were "injurious to another in their trade, business, or profession". Since Wolff has openly said that he isn't sure of all his facts, and hopes his book will eventually force Trump to resign, I'd guess there would be a good case on both scores. For example, with respect to "injurious to another in their trade, business, or profession", the book has already been cited by governments unfriendly to the US, e.g. North Korea and Iran, as proof that Trump is mentally incompetent.
Another interesting piece of evidence, as pointed out by the publisher's attorney, is that Trump's cease-and-desist letter failed to identify any factually false or defamatory statements. I think the problem, from Trump's point of view, is simple: most or all of the book is in fact true.
Rating: really liked it
Posted at Heradas
This book doesn't challenge your assumptions. If it is to be believed, the day-to-day functioning of Trump’s White House appears to be simultaneously worse than we all imagined, and exactly as we all thought it probably was: Trump’s an idiot, the least self-aware person alive, interested only in his own celebrity and validation, and wholly unqualified to be the President of anything. Everyone around him is 1) Trying to save face. 2) Pushing their competing agendas. 3) Making fun of Trump. 4) Stabbing each other in the back. 5) Pulling their hair out. 6) Trying to avoid jail time. 7) Competing for Trump’s attention. 8) Trying to rein Trump in. 9) Trying not to get fired. 10) Trying to get everyone else fired. 11) Failing miserably at everything they do, because they themselves are wholly inept, and generally awful humans.
All things considered, it was a surprisingly compassionate portrayal of everyone involved. It’s the blind leading the blind leading us all off a cliff.
P.S. Pence is mostly absent from the book, which makes it seem like he’s just sitting on the sidelines, twirling his thumbs, waiting for the moment he can step in and become President.
Rating: really liked it
**Knock knock** Uh… hello? Mr. *president? I’m sorry to just walk in to the oval office, but no one was at the desk and the door was wide open. Should that be?
Trump: “Yeah, I have trouble finding people willing to work for me, so I just leave the door open and let people wander in. Who are you? I hope you’re not from CNN.”
“No sir. My name is Michael Wolff, I’m an author and I want to write a book about you, your administration, and your first year in office. The working title is “The Great Transition: The first 100 Days of the Trump Adiministration”, yeah, that’s the ticket ….hey, have you lost weight? You look amazing!”
“I do look amazing. I’m the most amazing looking *president of all time…. Everyone says so. Come in and sit on the couch and never leave. I like you because you like me. You have the best taste. Here, have a laminated electoral map of the United states, see all the red? So much red, I won bigly.”
Wolff: “Thank you sir, I’m sure the red has nothing to do with mostly empty landmass.”
Trump: “Let me introduce you to the cast….um…. the people who work for me. Don’t ask me what they do, because I’m not sure what they do. This is my son in law, Jared Kushner. He’s going to bring peace to the Middle East because he’s Jewish. It’s a done deal!”
Wolff: “Wow! That’s almost impossible to believe, nice to meet you Jared.”
Jared: “……………….. Inaudible…………”
Trump: “This is
Baby Ivanka, my
wife daughter.”
Wolff: (throws up in mouth a little bit) “Hi Ivanka. Do you have a position here? “
Ivanka: “I think I’m an adviser or something. I sit here and look good and I never have an expression on my face.”
((Jared + Ivanka = Jarvanka. This is true.))
Wolff: “Who’s that woman in the corner? The one sobbing and covering her face, is she okay?”
Trump: “That’s Melania, my trophy wife. She’s been crying like that since election night.”
Wolff: “Me too.”
Trump: “What?”
Wolff: “Nothing….carry on with the introductions.”
“This is Reince Priebus. He gets me covfefe and fetches anything I tell him too.”
Reince: “I’m the Chief of Staff to the *president. Nice to meet you, (whispers) kill me and end this please.”
Trump: “This is Michael Flynn, he’s my ‘in’ with Putin.”
Flynn: “Actually, I’m the National Security Adviser AND the guy in charge of the Russia stuff. How’s it going?”
Wolff: “I’m feeling a bit nauseous, to be honest.”
Trump: “This is Sean Spicer. He goes on TV and talks to the fake news reporters, but I don’t think he looks the part.”
“Hi Michael. I’m the Press Secretary and it’s my job to lie outlandishly for the *president every day, and if I do a good job he won’t scream at me for hours.”
Trump: “This is
my daughter Hope Hicks. She’s pretty.”
“Hello Hope, I didn’t see you down there….are you steaming the *president’s pants whilst he’s in them?”
“Yes. He enjoys it. I’m the White House Communications Director.”
Wolff: “Really? The position Bradley Whitford played in the West Wing? …huh.”
Hope: “Who? Well, as far as I know my job is to worship the *president, agree with everything he says, and make him feel good about himself at all times. I do my best to make sure he doesn’t hear anything negative about himself.”
Wolff: “So you’re a feminist.”
Hope: “What?”
Wolff: “Nevermind.”
Trump: “This is
president Steve Bannon.”
“Hey there Michael, believe it or not I’m the White House Chief of Staff….. Toby from The West Wing. How are you?”
Wolff: “Kind of regretting my life decisions at the moment. Are you wearing two shirts? Forget it… Mr. *President, do you mind if I interview, and record, everyone that comes in here?”
Trump: “Sure! You’re a good guy because you like me. I know it’s going to be a great book. Any book about Trump is the best book! You’re only going to write nice things, right, because you like me?”
Wolff: “But of course! Heh heh…”
If you pay close attention to the clusterfuck that is happening in this country, nothing in this book will surprise you. If not, defiantly read it and get caught up. Most of this stuff has been reported by pundits for the last couple of years, but there is plenty in here to bring one a bit of schadenfreude, which makes it worth the read. But the best thing about the book is that it's making Trump pooh his pants.
A couple of fun facts that I learned was the *president yells at the cleaning staff (and everyone for everything all the time) for picking up clothing that he left on the floor, stating that ‘if the shirt is on the floor it’s because that’s where he wants it.’
He prefers fast food because he has a phobia of being poisoned. His (ir)rationale is that the McDonald's has no idea he’s showing up, so there is no chance they can plan on the poisoning. Yes, the food is poison and it kills one just as dead, only a bit slower. Don’t tell him.
Oh, and he likes to go to bed with a cheeseburger. Go whichever direction you wish with that information. I was reminded in the comments by Susan (the other Susan), that he also insists on stripping his bed every morning instead of letting the staff do it. Why? His diet (intestinal issues?) The nighty night cheeseburger? Who can say?
We, the citizens of the United States, are in danger. Our Democracy is in trouble. We must come out and vote for Democrats in the midterms in such numbers that the shenanigans by the republicans to keep us from voting will be unsuccessful. Make sure you’re registered now, and near Election Day. If everyone takes one other person who has never voted to the polls with them it will be more than enough to flip one, if not both houses. It’s the absolutely vital we flip them. Our lives depend on it.
A reckoning is coming… 11-6-18. Save the date!
*illegitimate, fake, not an actual president
Rating: really liked it
Kinetic, trashy, slapdash, and completely addictive. Wolff's prose is uneven but he is very good at keeping the eye moving across the page, and in this he is perhaps helped by the book's failing: this is very padded out with stuff we already know (the long profiles of Kushner, Bannon, and Conway have no revelations in them.) But the gossip is gold, though the depictions of the characters have an unfortunate tendency toward lazy meanness. I don't need a description of Bannon as "on the spectrum," I just want to read "Might he be the worst manager who ever lived? He might."
WHAT IT TAKES, Richard Ben Cramer's recounting of the 1988 presidential election, is one of the 15 best books I've ever read, and it has what this book lacks: a zoom-out, a perspective, on America itself, and insight on the varying reasons people might run for President. In contrast, Trump is unusually absent from FIRE AND FURY, a blank spot of mysticism and derision. But the rush is fun, and that has its value. The epilogue, in which Bannon (surely the source of almost everything in here) muses about running for president himself, will stick with me. 3.51 stars.
In case you're not interested in wading through, I've pulled out the quotes that grabbed me, and will leave them here:
“You need a son of a bitch as your chief of staff. And you need a son of a bitch who knows Washington,” Ailes told Trump not long after the election. “You’ll want to be your own son of a bitch, but you don’t know Washington.” Ailes had a suggestion: “Speaker Boehner.” (John Boehner had been the Speaker of the House until he was forced out in a Tea Party putsch in 2011.) “Who’s that?” asked Trump."
"Scarborough and Brzezinski said it was all still complicated, and not public, officially, but it was good and everything was getting resolved.
“You guys should just get married,” prodded Trump.
“I can marry you! I’m an Internet Unitarian minister,” Kushner, otherwise an Orthodox Jew, said suddenly.
“What?” said the president. “What are you talking about? Why would they want you to marry them when I could marry them? When they could be married by the president! At Mar-a-Lago!”
He reprimanded the housekeeping staff for picking up his shirt from the floor: “If my shirt is on the floor, it’s because I want it on the floor.” Then he imposed a set of new rules: nobody touch anything, especially not his toothbrush. (He had a longtime fear of being poisoned, one reason why he liked to eat at McDonald’s—nobody knew he was coming and the food was safely premade.) Also, he would let housekeeping know when he wanted his sheets done, and he would strip his own bed."
“I like Flynn, he reminds me of my uncles,” said Bannon. “But that’s the problem: he reminds me of my uncles."
Then McMaster, wearing a uniform with his silver star, came in and immediately launched into a wide-ranging lecture on global strategy. Trump was soon, and obviously, distracted, and as the lecture continued he began sulking.
“That guy bores the shit out of me,” announced Trump after McMaster left the room. But Kushner pushed him to take another meeting with McMaster, who the next day showed up without his uniform and in a baggy suit.
“He looks like a beer salesman,” Trump said, announcing that he would hire McMaster but didn’t want to have another meeting with him."
"For most of the day, almost no one would know that he had decided to take matters into his own hands. In presidential annals, the firing of FBI director James Comey may be the most consequential move ever made by a modern president acting entirely on his own."
"Moving from the cabinet room across the open area into the president’s earshot, “a loud, scary, clearly threatening” Bannon, in the Jarvanka telling, yelled, “I am going to fuck you and your little group!” with a baffled president plaintively wanting to know, “What’s going on?”
“Look, Kasowitz has known him for twenty-five years. Kasowitz has gotten him out of all kinds of jams. Kasowitz on the campaign—what did we have, a hundred women? Kasowitz took care of all of them.” - Bannon.
Rating: really liked it
this is what happens when you let a Wolff into your House, silly!
Rating: really liked it
**2.5 Stars**
Disturbed! No I'm not talking about Trump - disturbed is how I felt on finishing this book. To use an alleged quote by Sean Spicer " You can't make this shit up"
Accusations fly in all directions throughout this book, but as to whether any of these accusations can be substantiated, is another matter, though to be fair to the author, Trump appears to be surrounded by incompetent and politically inexperienced people and I include the man himself in that too. I don't profess to be well informed on American politics, but it's clear that something is very wrong in the White House. Trump's advisors seem unable to reign him in, as is clearly demonstrated by his rants on social media. I honestly worry for the US in particular, and the rest of the world in general, if just a fraction of this book is factual. It also speaks volumes to me, that the leader of one of the greatest nations on earth appears to be proud of the fact that he doesn’t read, and has never bought a text book ( he certainly doesn't come out of it with any dignity ).We all recognise on Goodreads just how much knowledge is to be gained from reading, and how our understanding of other people's views is expanded.
I don’t think this book was particularly well written, it certainly didn't flow, and there were numerous grammatical/ editing issues. I also question whether there were any real revelations here, especially to those of you in the US. All in all a real disappointment that left me with even more concerns than I already had!
Rating: really liked it
The day Trump was elected President of the USA the world let out a collective gasp, a gasp of absolute horror as the unbelievable actually happened: an unqualified misogynistic climate change denier became one of the most powerful men in the world. I remember walking into work that evening and the atmosphere was utterly dead. Nobody knew quite what to say as even in England we were dismayed and horror struck: we were numb.
A strong degree of uncertainty and tension spread over the world. We all watched. We all anticipated. We all worried about what this man was capable of doing, of what he might do with the power that was (and still is) at his disposal. All he had to do was push a button and he could send us all into a third world war, one year on and that uncertainty is still here. I get anxious when I read about the provoking tweets he has spread across social media. I get anxious when I hear about the tension between the USA and North Korea. Trump makes me anxious.
Fire and Fury does nothing to ease such feelings; it is sensationalist and it only serves to fan the fires of worry. But we should be worried; we should all be so terribly worried about what this man may do next. But does that make this book good? Does it make this book factually correct and impartial? From the opening of my review, it is very clear that I am not impartial but that does not mean that a book that seeks to defame Trump would necessarily be enjoyable for me. If this was written well, with care, thought and a critical mind-set, it would have wielded far more persuasive power.
There’s only one reason this book has become so popular and has sold so many copies: Trump didn’t want us to read it so, naturally, we all wanted to. There’s nothing quite like banned (or attempted-banned) literature to peak the interest of the reading public. What’s in this book that Trump didn’t want us to see? What’s in this book that he would try to hide from a world that openly criticises his buffoonery already? Absolutely nothing. Trump haters: there’s nothing in this book that you did not already know.
I wanted dirt, real dirt: I wanted drama and I wanted even more reason to hate this guy. Instead I got a few details, but not anything of a surprising nature. I learnt that the operations of the White House under his leadership are a complete shambles. Shock horror! But the thing that really let the book down was its sheer lack of evidence. I have no confidence in what Wolff has written. He is a journalist, but this is bad journalism. There are no references and very few of his interviewees were willing to actually go on the record.
So the end result is a book that I simply cannot trust. I lost my faith with it after reading the three page prologue, where Wolff explained why he has little support to back up his claims; certainly, not a good start for any book: it felt gossipy, fake and like it was written for a trashy tabloid newspaper.
Rating: really liked it
FIVE STARSWhen I heard that Trump tried to stop the release of this book...well, look out! The only thing I can't stand more than Trump is a flagrantly unconstitutional book ban. I hate to pay retail for books, but I did. I could only get my hands on an audio copy, since apparently the entire city of Portland was sold out the minute the stores opened. You could say I HAD TO READ THIS BOOK just to spite Trump. Thank you, Audible, for fulfilling that instant gratification need.
In the words attributed to Sean Spicer, "you can't make this shit up." I agree. The book is highly readable, salacious and dishy. You get a real feel of how Trump is (was) influenced by Bannon on one side and the "Jarvanka" moderates on the other. Most of the juicy "domestic" scenes have been released already, who can get that picture out of their head---Trump climbing into bed at 6:30 with his cheeseburger and Coke and three tv sets on? Gives me chills to think of an American President acting the way he does on a daily basis.
On one hand, I found the flow of the book a little awkward. But on the other hand, that makes it easy to pick up and start reading from any chapter. While traveling in a mostly forward timeline beginning from Trump's campaign up until now, each chapter is centered around a single person or single event that occurred during Trump's first year in the White House. Mostly, I was shouting at anyone who would listen: ooh, I forgot about that, oh yeah, and when he did that, ooh! It is a condensed version of all the craziness we have endured for the last year.
I don't know how much is true, if the verbatim quotes are accurate and attributed to the correct character. There is a lot of "summarizing" of conversations by Wolff. However, he has obviously done his biographical research and I enjoyed reading the history and backgrounds of many in Trump's inner circle. Did you know, for example, that Jared Kushner had a very similar family dynamic to Ivanka's? He was always desperate for his father's approval and was required to kiss him on greeting and call him Daddy. Ick.
If even 15% of this book is true, we are in trouble. But, we already know that. As fun as it is to find out what really is going on in the Whitehouse, you will finish this book feeling worse than before. I'm sorry.
#resist
GET OUT AND VOTE, PEOPLE!🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
Rating: really liked it
There has been a lot of commentary on this book since it was released, a lot of it about how sloppy the journalism is. Others have said that the book really only mirrors back to us what we already knew about Trump. I have to say that I’m more in the second camp than the first. I raced through this, not because I was expecting any spoilers, most of those were in the papers days before the book was available anyway. I also find it amusing that the person most damaged by the book seems to have been Steve Bannon.
People do say that it takes a few years before you can get an accurate fix on the present – but one of the things this book does is to press ‘replay’ on what has been a crazy year. And since almost every day has brought yet another reason for my jaw to bounce off the table, having everything replayed reminds me that if I was in anyway sensible I would give up reading newspapers and following the news.
I don’t pretend to understand the American psyche. I can think of no excuse for Trump – somehow millions of people voted for a complete psycho. I don’t watch television – but I’ve since seen some of his ‘work’ as a reality TV star – what in the name of Jesus were you thinking, America when you voted for this tosser? This is a mistake that could well end the planet.
I used to have a theory about stupid people and power. I’ve worked for people who have been pretty dumb and one of the things that seems to always happen with them is that they do two things that trap themselves in their own stupidity. The first is the need to have an opinion on just about everything. So much so that they just pull the first thing out of their bum that pops into their mind. The problem then is that their pride makes it impossible to change their mind. This is actually the same problem – dumb people are almost completely incapable of saying ‘I don’t know’ (the next time you find yourself saying ‘I don’t know’, say it with pride). So, they jump and then, once they have jumped, they can’t be seen to take a step back. Pride means they have to defend the position they jumped into based on no forethought whatsoever. So, the twin problem is having to have an opinion on everything and never being able to back down.
But Trump is slightly different to this kind of stupidity – he does change his mind, he just doesn’t admit that he has done it. It is even possible that he doesn’t even know that he has changed his mind. He is interesting (if that is the right word) because he needs constant reassurance. The phrase ‘man-baby’ could have been coined to describe him. And he needs to feel he has won. He is the living embodiment of that quote from Nietzsche, “I have done that', says my memory. I cannot have done that—says my pride and remains unshakeable. Finally—memory yields”. As the author says, Trump sees every interaction as a zero-sum competition – in which he either wins or loses. No other alternative is available.
But of all the quotable parts of this book, the quote that has gotten under my skin and made me dislike this idiot even more than I thought it was possible for me to hate him already, was this quote:
“Trump liked to say that one of the things that made life worth living was getting your friends’ wives into bed. In pursuing a friend’s wife, he would try to persuade the wife that her husband was perhaps not what she thought. Then he’d have his secretary ask the friend into his office; once the friend arrived, Trump would engage in what was, for him, more or less constant sexual banter. Do you like having sex with your wife? How often? You must have had a better fuck than your wife? Tell me about it. I have girls coming in from Los Angeles at three o’clock. We can go upstairs and have a great time. I promise… And all the while, Trump would have his friend’s wife on the speakerphone, listening in.”
Think about this for a minute. Here is a man who, to achieve a sense of winning over someone he knows, is prepared to destroy that person’s and their wife’s relationship. To be completely frank, I’m not as troubled by the idea that people might have an affair – although, the idea of anyone sleeping with Trump seems somewhat surprising to me. Still, I’ve never understood what women find attractive about men or, in fact, why they aren’t all lesbians. All the same, I think most relationships survive adultery, sex really doesn’t mean nearly as much as people make it out to mean. What does mean a lot is love – and I would be prepared to bet that no one has ever fucked Trump for love. That he has found a way to have sex with the wives of friends by attacking the love between a married couple is unconscionable. I’m surprised by how annoyed this has made me.
That Trump would set up a friend (or even an enemy) like this just to be able to sleep with their wife is beyond belief. I would like to believe that this is a lie or part of the ‘sloppy journalism’ mentioned above – but the problem is that it is almost impossible not to believe it of this man. And that is the problem. Coming up to the election he would, about once a week, do something so shockingly repulsive (mock a disabled person, talk about grabbing women by the pussy, say he could shoot a random person in the street and still get elected, physically stalk and intimidate Clinton on stage) that I honestly felt it was impossible for him to be elected. I’m not talking about anything based on sloppy journalism here, just facts about him all known prior to him being elected.
Now I can’t think of a single thing I could learn about this man that I would doubt him being capable of. He strikes me as completely lacking in morality, as someone without the mental capacity to understand what morality even means.
And that the American people have handed such a man ultimate power and put the rest of us at risk of this lunatic. Build four walls – put on a roof.
Rating: really liked it
Lots of fun, except it's not. Reads like a parody, except it's not. *Dies*
Wolff is a lively raconteur, to say the least. "Sardonic" is just the beginning for him. Overall this was an enjoyable read, if reading about how low your country can go could ever be considered enjoyable. But hey I'm not a big fan of the world in general, so I will find my pleasures where I can.
I pretty much read this like I read fiction because that's the most enjoyable way for me to read nonfiction. Did the story captivate me? Yes. How was the writing? A solid 3 stars, I liked it. Did the book resonate? I suppose it did, to an extent. But this is coming from a guy who still can't believe that Trump was elected in the first place. Part of my job is in public policy; I also work with people who are often fucked over by various governments... I need to create some distance when I'm off work time. And so the only way I can stay upbeat in this fucked up world - being all too familiar with the actual results of decisions made by various malicious idiots in power - is to create some layers between me and this world's leaders. And so I view them through a reality tv lens. Don't shame me, I'm already ashamed.
Anyway, on that note, Jarvanka versus Bannon was
delicious. Really the best ongoing narrative (mainly due to Russia collusion narrative being dull and predictable; I mean seriously, am I supposed to be surprised?)... those three are
hilar. The story of how they divided the White House and battled for Trump's attention was like watching a cross between reality tv show Big Brother and some very serious HBO prestige drama about ego-based battles for dominance, delivered with shades of Larry David and um Fellini.
Also I just youtubed the amazing battle royale of Jake Tapper (wonderfully suave and condescending) versus Stephen Miller (hilariously stoned cretin) and that was equally amusing. Am I even living in the real world? This can't be the real world. *Dies*
But back to the book... the ongoing question of whether Trump is mentally ill or just an idiot was fun. But also not. Sorta like the whole book!
